Definition of ‘Holocaust Survivors’

Date: Wed, 13 Aug 1997 16:17:20 CDT
From: Adina Mishkoff mailto:[email protected]
Organization: AMCHA
Subject: Number of living Holocaust survivors
cc: AMCHA office mailto:[email protected]
To: Multiple recipients of list H-HOLOCAUST mailto:H [email protected]

Shalom,

We have seen several inquiries in the past regarding the number of living Holocaust survivors.

A recent committee put together by the Israeli Prime Minister’s Office in relation to other research being conducted was charged with the task of defining who is a holocaust survivor and estimating the number of survivors living today worldwide.

The committee came up with the following based on discussions with researchers and experts in the field as well as commmissioning studies to complement existing data:

A. Definition of the term “Holocaust survivor”:

A Holocaust survivor will be defined as any Jew who lived in a country at the time when it was:

  • under Nazi regime
  • under Nazi occupation
  • under regime of Nazi collaborators as well as any Jew who fleed due to the above regime or occupation.
B. Estimates of living Holocaust survivors:
Israel: Between 360,000 — 380,000
FSU 184,000 — 220,000
USA 140,000 — 160,000
Western Europe 80,000 — 100,000
Eastern Europee 50,000 — 80,000
Other countries 20,000 — 20,000
TOTAL 834,000 — 960,000

Hopefully this will answer all those who have posed this question recently.

All the best,

Adina Mishkoff

Administrative Asst/AMCHA, Jerusalem


Webmaster note: By this definition, a Jew who lived under the Nazi regime or under Nazi occupation could have been a collaborator with the Nazis, and STILL be considered a “Holocaust survivor.”

On the other hand, Jews who were sent to the gulags by the Soviet state prior to the German invasion in 1941 are not considered “Holocaust survivors.” Presumably, Jews killed by the Soviet state are not “victims of the Holocaust.” They’re just dead.

Most amazingly, Jews who left Europe in 1933 or 1934 for America and elsewhere, and who lived a cushy life while the war raged in Europe, are considered “Holocaust survivors.”

History and remembrance don’t mix

Six Candles But No Enlightenment

  • A Holocaust Commemoration Marred

One survivor remarked in Yiddish, “Her speech to this audience was like serving pig to Chassidim”. The guest speaker was a historian on Yom Hashoah, Holocaust Remembrance Day, May 4, 1997. Grandmothers and grandfathers came to the JCC on the Palisades in Tenafly, New Jersey to show their children and grandchildren how important it is to remember. Six families came to light six candles for the six million whose lives were snuffed out in the Holocaust. It was a small gesture for such a large loss. But the symbolism was powerful. The presence of survivors and their families was a concrete reminder that Jews are linked to the past and to the future. Unfortunately, many people there thought that the tone, solemn and respectful, was marred by a misguided guest speaker who did not understand the audience and insulted the memory and solemnity of the occasion.

Dr. Atina Grossman, made highly controversial remarks concerning the suffering of Germans in postwar Berlin. She made suggestions and innuendos regarding Jewish life in postwar Berlin that the audience found hurtful and inappropriate.

The speaker at first appeared to realize that her research might not be appropriate for this forum. She remarked apologetically, “It is very difficult to mix history and remembrance … I’m not even sure it should be done.” […]

[…]


Source:

by Miryam Z. Wahrman, Ph.D.

Jewish Communication Network: Miryam Wahrman

The Science Scene

Nothing to fear from the truth

Human Rights Tribunal hearings

In May of 1997, the Holocaust Lobby called a Dr. Frederick Schweitzer as one of its expert witnesses.

(Defense Attorney Doug) Christie: I want to make sure I understand. I don’t mean to insult you; I may be very stupid, and I apologize if I am. When you said “no,” I take it the answer is “no” to the question: “Can truth be anti-Semitic?” The answer is “no,” right?

Schweitzer: Right. I don’t think Jews have any fear of the truth.

Move over Christiaan Barnard

Ilona Sugar was released as a very sick woman from a German concentration camp exactly 32 years ago. Sadistic Nazi doctors had performed medical experiments on her. They transplanted her heart to the right and her liver to the left without any anesthesia. This is known as vivisection. To this day Mrs. Sugar has not received a penny of restitution from Germany.

Continue reading

your crap

how’s about a bullet to your brain? you know it’s just a matter of time til some pissed-off JDL commando comes and blows whatever pitiful tissue that you have in your head all over your bed. you are one dumb fucker for making this your cause and thinking the 1st amendment is gonna save your ass cause the 4th amendent gives them the right to come gunnin’ for you.

Continue reading

your stories

my father,75 years old had a wife and 2 kids,one 2 year old a boy .and a 1 year old girl,they arrived in treblinka in june 1942 ,they are dead,thats a FACT,now tell me where they are?,or maybe they just went for a walk and got lost?,allso my dad had 5 brothres,and 2 sisters,this poor souls had the luck to be send to auschwitz,another “work camp”,,,,i dont have a problem with your theory ,i am just wondering i KNOW of MY FAMILY and there are at least 85 pepole dead,so the number 6 million make sense to me,and if you are so sure its all a hoax,WHERE ARE THIS PEPOLE?

[[email protected]]